James, are you doing 1/2 strokes until you can easily shave arm hair along the entire length of the blade? if I do that that and then add a few drops of water to the slurry and do 30-50 regular x strokes I can get a good violin going on at this stage, with the hht test on a good day, remember not to let the slurry get thick, it dulls the edge big time.
After that it is just a case of refining that edge, either 2 drops water every 30 or so strokes until on water then rinse hone and blade and do 50 on water only, or go unicot and tape the spine, add 3 drops water to the slurry and do 30 regular x strokes, then rinse off and do 50 on water, hht at this stage using either method wants to be a loud violin at worst and a catch and pop if its gone really well, if its not there then another 50 on water and test again, you can repeat until you get a catch and pop, then and only then strop 60 canvas and 60 leather, and if you made sure each of the above stages were reached before moving forward you should find the hht is a pop pop pop.
Thats how I do it more or less , and I am very very happy with the edges I get, hope this helps.