ShavingUniverse.com

Register a free account now!

If you are registered, you get access to the members only section, can participate in the buy & sell second hand forum and last but not least you can reserve your preferred username before someone else takes it.

Coticule vs Whetstone

smalltank

Member
I am totally new to all of these things and all I wanna do is re-edge my razors when green paste and stropping dont help 2x a year most likely...I dont wanna spend alot of cash..though I did read a Chinese 12k puts an edge as good as other stones..just takes longer 50-100 strokes vs a coticule at 10-20 strokes..do Coticules work on kitchen knifes as well?

ST
 
Coticules work on anything that you need to sharpen, from chisels to knives to razors.

I'd get one over a Chinese 12K...:thumbup:
 
The Coticule top trumps the C12K everytime for me, and I own both, It's a lot more versatile. And the shave simply do not compare
My money goes on the Coticule

Regards
Ralfson (Dr)
 
I owned 2 CH "12k" stones from different sources and did not like either. If you are going to use paste at the end, I am not sure if it really matters that much what stone you use before it.
 
I understand you want to maintain the edge on your razor with stropping on leather, and when that no longer brings the edge to peak condition, a touch-up on a strop with "green paste". Is this green paste the Dovo green paste or a Chromium oxide based green paste? Both are green, but otherwise very different.

After a couple of months, your pasted strop no longer seems to be able to bring the edge back, and you are looking for a whetstone that can bring the edge back within reach of the pasted strop, right?
That is a much used strategy for maintaining a good edge on a razor, and probably one of the easiest.

A Chinese 12K stone will not be of much use for that strategy. It is more a type of stone that finishes the edge, than a stone you can use for bevel correction. Bevel correction is what you will be doing. A Coticule is quite capable to do that, but it won't be with 10 or 20 laps. It depends on the abrasive properties of the paste you're using and on the type of pasted strop, how much the bevel of your razor will turn into an arc after a couple of months of touch-ups. It is the belly of this arc, that the whetstone must remove. The more pronounced the arc, the more work you'll need to do on the whetstone.
I have a couple of returning "customers" (I don't charge them, so they are not really customers), that rely on this method, but bring in their razors for the bevel work on the Coticule. By that experience, I know it can take quite a bit of work, certainly when more abrasive pastes have been used for the touch-ups. The time it takes can be in between 5 and 15 minutes. It might be best to get a Coticule from a faster layer. (There are couple of different Coticule veins, and the main difference is the speed at which they can remove steel when used with an abrasive slurry).
Coticules are an ecellent choice for this kind of work. In fact, that have been used for that for centuries, by many barbers.

Kind regards,
Bart.
 
tat2Ralfy said:
kinematic said:
smalltank said:
do Coticules work on kitchen knifes as well?

Razors and kitchen knives are both made of steel so no, they will only sharpen razors.

This is of course a joke :)

Coticules work very well on kitchen knives, and wood working tools etc.etc.
http://www.coticule.be/the-cafeteria/message/7842.html


Regards
Ralfson (Dr)

Pataxori, the Spanish dealer of Ardennes coticule, told me that the hardest cotis are sold and used by plastic surgeons, because they give a clean edge to the micro-chisels used for the bones (nose).
 
Back
Top