Ah yes, the
Stockholm Syndrome of straight razor shaving. I upgraded 10 of my 5-6/8 razors to 7/8 or 8/8 razors over the past 12 months. I like the aesthetics of wider blades better, and quite honestly, an 8/8 Henckels Friodur is simply something every man should have in his bathroom.
Now here is the USD 100 question: "Will it shave better than a 5/8 no name Solingen vintage?" And the answer is, "it depends." The term "better" implies an inherent, measurable quality that simply does not exist once the razor changes its owner. I had a number of razors I absolutely hated, and others swore by. Wade & Butcher? No bloody way. Dubl Duck? You have to be joking (or offer it to me for under USD 100 in mint condition, in which case I would gladly take it because they
are nice razors).
So, there is absolutely no way anyone in his right mind would predict how a 7 or 8/8 razor and your old wrinkly face would get along. Zero. Nada. Keiner.
So why the reference to the Stockholm Syndrome? Because somebody with a lot of clout once said that Meat Choppers were the bomb. And people believed him. And Meat Chopper prices skyrocketed. And they became reasonably rare. And people paid even more for them. And then they found (well, I did, although I only paid about USD 50 for mine) that they sucked. Well, mine did, and for me. But everyone else kept banging on about how they were totally fantastic übershavers blah-blah-blah. And then, all of a sudden, someone reviewed the Filarmonica EPBD, and their prices skyrocketed. And... You know the drill. Long story short: There are still many, many 7 or 8/8 blades out there. I will leave it to Cedric to comment on what blanks they were ground from.
So, get one if you can. I got my 7/8 Friodurs for about USD 75, and that is a fair price. Might take some time to find one, but if you can, get one (mine was NOS). 8/8 Wackers? Might want to get one, because just
might go out of production. 8/8 Revisoren? I have one. I like it a lot. It's a big, chunky blade, but with a nice hollow grind, and good manoeuvrability (the key factor for me when it comes to big blades). Just keep trying. I have seen a few rather nice trades happen here in the marketplace, and I think that is a great thing. Some of us, myself included, should just stop buying razors. Paul just wrote
a fantastic little piece about how ADs retard learning. Buying less, buying quality - and sticking with it is, I think, key.
But, yes, I think anyone who wants to convince you that because expensive, big razor X or Y work for him, they must also work for you, has a lot of learning to do still. What the shaving scene needs is less AD ridden fanboys, and more people willing to thoroughly explore one tool after the other, and review them in a meaningful way.